

Lawyer Salvador Paolo A. Panelo Jr., spokesperson for Vice President Sara Duterte, has defended his remarks against the Senate Impeachment Court, invoking constitutional protections on freedom of expression following the issuance of a show-cause order against him.
In a statement dated November 20, Panelo cited Supreme Court rulings emphasizing that the power to punish for contempt does not exempt courts from public scrutiny or legitimate criticism.
He quoted the ruling in Garcia Jr. v. Manrique, which states that “Every citizen has the right to comment upon and criticize the actuations of public officers,” even when such criticism is directed at judicial authority.
He also cited Tolentino v. Heydarian, stressing that public discussions on matters of paramount public interest should be allowed without fear of punishment, warning courts against using contempt powers to suppress critical speech.
“I welcome the opportunity to demonstrate that my comments were fair, made in good faith, and did not impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice, and are thus constitutionally protected,” Panelo said.
He added that he would formally respond to the show-cause order within the prescribed period upon receiving it.
The Senate Impeachment Court issued the order on Friday following a motion by Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo, who questioned Panelo's public remarks accusing several senator-judges of showing bias against Duterte during the impeachment proceedings.
Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero explained that although Panelo was not covered by Rule 18 of the impeachment court's rules, he could still fall under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court concerning contempt.
