

The Senate impeachment court on Friday issued a show-cause order against Vice President Sara Duterte's spokesperson, lawyer Paolo Panelo, over his remarks alleging that several senator-judges were showing bias against his client.
During the day 45 of Duterte’s impeachment trial, the order followed a motion filed by Senator-Judge Erwin Tulfo, which was approved by Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz“ Escudero without objection.
Tulfo argued that Panelo was neither a party to the impeachment proceedings, a witness, nor a lawyer of record, yet had publicly commented on the conduct of the trial and the actions of the senator-judges.
“He's not party to this case, pero siya po ang tagapagsalita ng Vice Presidente. Tama po ba yun? I believe parang meron problema ho rito. I mean, you are the spokesperson of the vice president na on trial here and then makakomento ka hanggang sa mga senator judges or the impeachment court,” Tulfo said.
Tulfo sought the court’s action after Panelo accused senator-judges Raffy Tulfo, Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan, and Risa Hontiveros of unfairly questioning the credibility and expertise of defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente during Thursday’s impeachment trial.
Tulfo initially proposed requiring Panelo to explain his statements, raising the possibility of summoning him before the impeachment court.
Escudero, meanwhile, clarified that Panelo was not covered by Rule 18 of the impeachment court's rules, which concerns restrictions on public statements about pending proceedings, as he was neither a party nor a lawyer or witness in the case.
However, Escudero said the court could exercise authority over Panelo under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court, which covers contempt.
He added that, under the suppletory application of the Rules of Court, Panelo could still be subject to the authority of the impeachment court in relation to statements or actions connected to the proceedings.
“Attorney Panelo is neither a lawyer of record nor a witness to this impeachment court. Neither is he a party and therefore not covered by Rule 18. However, given the suppletory application of the rules of court particularly Rule 71 on contempt he may be covered or under the authority of this court, not under Rule 18 of our impeachment rules, but under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court,” Escudero said.
Escudero then clarified whether Tulfo wanted to proceed with a show-cause order instead of simply asking Panelo to explain his remarks.
“If I understand the motion instead of asking him to explain, it'll be in the form of a show cause order. honorable Senator Judge Erwin, is that your pleasure, sir?,” Escudero asked.
“Yes, Mister Presiding Officer. That's my point, sir. Therefore file a motion to issue a show cause order for for the spokesperson of the vice president,’ Tulfo said.
With no senator-judge objecting, the impeachment court approved the motion and directed the clerk of court to issue a show-cause order to Panelo.
