

A brief exchange of remarks between House prosecutor Rep. Chel Diokno and defense counsel Mark Vinluan caused tension at the Senate impeachment court during the 44th day of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Thursday, November 19.
The exchange began when Diokno questioned the relevance of the defense’s line of questioning for witness, lawyer and accountant Rainer Dela Fuente, a former investigator with the AMLC Secretariat’s Compliance and Investigation Group, particularly his expertise in anti-money laundering.
Diokno argued that Duterte was not facing money laundering charges, saying the issues before the impeachment court centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of her Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN), and alleged participation in business.
“May I know the relevance of this line of questioning? The witness apparently is delivering his credentials on anti-money laundering, but the respondent on this case is not being charged on any money-laundering crimes,” Diokno said.
“The issues before this court are all centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of SALN, and participation in business. And I haven't heard anything from this witness that would qualify him on those matters,” he added.
Vinluan countered that the Articles of Impeachment contained allegations related to money laundering and other related matters.
“To correct the good counsel, there are actually allegations under the Articles of Impeachment pertaining to money laundering and other related matters. So we will tackle that issue later on," Vinluan said.
The two lawyers then exchanged remarks.
“I would beg to…” Diokno.
“At any rate, Your Honor,” Vinluan interjected.
“Your Honor, I don’t like being interrupted,” Diokno said.
“If I may be allowed to finish?” Vinluan responded.
Senate President Francis Escudero, who presided over the proceedings, reminded Diokno to allow the defense counsel to finish his statement.
Vinluan maintained that the defense had the prerogative to present its own expert witness, noting that the prosecution had also presented an Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) witness and offered interpretations of the agency’s data.
The dispute stemmed from Diokno’s objection to the defense’s apparent presentation of Dela Fuente as an expert witness on anti-money laundering, arguing that such qualifications were not directly indicated in the defense’s offer of testimony.
Escudero eventually allowed the defense to seek Dela Fuente’s opinion on matters being discussed before the court.
However, the presiding officer clarified that qualifying Dela Fuente as an expert would only allow him to provide his opinion on AMLC documents. It would not mean that his opinions were automatically correct or accurate.
